2009 Minimum Wage Increases - Will $5 Extra Really Help or Hurt
At the end of July the 2009 federal minimum wage jumps to $7.25 an hour from $6.55, according to the US department of Labor. However, many question if this will help or hurt low income workers and the small business that employ them.
The minimum wage has increased from $5.85 (2007) to $6.55 (2008) to the latest amount of $7.25. Most states have their own minimum wage, and employers are required to pay whichever is higher. That means minimum wage workers will get a raise in 29 states and Washington, D.C. In the remaining 21 states, they'll see no change. The increase to $7.25 means 70 cents more an hour for the lowest-paid workers in the 30 regions that have lower minimums or no minimum wage. It also means higher costs for employers who feel they've already trimmed all their operating fat.
Will the minimum wage increases (about $5 p/day) really make a difference for millions of Americans who are on minimum wage, already struggling with higher gas and food prices in one of the worst recessions on record? The minimum wage adjustment is an almost 12% raise, but most of it will be eaten up by inflation which is officially running at close to 5% annually - unofficially it is much higher with basic groceries up more than 20% in many states.
The minimum wage hike is "a drop in the bucket compared to the increases in costs, declining labor market, and declining household wealth that consumers have experienced in the past year," Lehman Brothers economist Zach Pandl said in a recent USA today article. The new minimum wage is less than the inflation-adjusted 1997 level of $7.02, and far below the inflation-adjusted level of $10.06 from 40 years ago, according to the Labor Department inflation calculator.
Some small businesses are already making plans to raise prices to offset the higher wages they have to pay their workers. "There just isn't any room for profit, and so this is why prices will have to go up," one small business owner said. "I have to recoup those costs." This will just further drive inflation and erode wages for everyone, and unless productivity improves we will end up in a vicious "wage-price inflation spiral". Still for a number of workers this mandated raise is better then nothing given most business were planning modest or no pay raises this year thanks to the tough economic climate.
What would you do with $5 extra a day, which is about $100 a month? Would it make a real difference in your life or would you fritter it away on unnecessary spending.
Related:
~ America's Income and Wealth Inequality
~ 10 ways to Quickly Improve Cash Flow
Liked what you read? Then consider subscribing (free) to get the latest articles delivered directly via RSS or Email
July 30, 2008 11:13 AM
I'm not a big fan of minimum wage laws. It would be nice if you could erase all the world's ills by simply requiring a minimum wage be paid, but the real world doesn't work like that. That said, I would probably just save an extra $100 if I had it. So I suppose it would be good for me.
July 30, 2008 1:05 PM
These boneheads, this is such a wedge issue it's not even funny. Less than one percent of the US working public makes minimum wage. Yet for some reason, Democrats rail about it, and business owners claim they have to raise prices to recoup costs.
Gimme a break already.
http://www.heritage.org/Research/labor/WM19.cfm
July 30, 2008 3:12 PM
$100 is a lot of money for me. It will pay gas for month and let me take my kids to movies. For me because my english not so good this is the only pay I get. My kids go to school here and so they will have better future.
July 30, 2008 7:10 PM
Hey Andy, you should check out Kudlow and Company on CNBC every night. He usually has great financial guests discussing the day on the stock market, and the economy in general. It's about the only program on CNBC I can tolerate. The rest of 'em are too brash and loud.
July 31, 2008 8:25 AM
Great post Andy, the part the wage law misses is that by what ever percentage the increase is so should all employers be forced to increase all wages by that percentage. Not just those at the minimum. So the minimum has gone up almost 12%, then the mailman, the truck driver, etc, all wages should go up. The raise in the cost of living has gone up dramatically by not changing everyone’s wages, we place those who where once just making it, to an almost poverty range.
July 31, 2008 9:11 AM
@ Kyle - I agree with you, but with no minimum wage a number of people could get exploited. Infact a number of "illegal" immigrants get paid way under wage which subsidizes the higher wages for the rest of us.
@ SB - A lot of the minimum wage earners are black and hispanic which are the largest minorties
and that's why the political implications. The headline "Single mother of 3 can't afford food for children on minumum wage" is not something the politicians want in the headlines. Espically in an election here and bad economic conditions. Will raising the minimum wage solve poverty? No.
@ Anonymous - You definetly are in a tough position because I could not imagine surviving on minimum wage in this coutry (espically in a large city). Congratulations on your goals to take care of your kids, and spending the money partially on them is a great idea.
@ SB - I have seen a bit of Kudlow, but find him similar to all the other lound CNBC's commentators. Besides with work, kids and the blog there is little time for TV. Perhaps I can TIVO it.
July 31, 2008 9:13 AM
@ the Tax guy. Your comment came in just as I published my responses to the other ones. Thanks for stopping by. Your points are correct and that's why as a nation on whole we are getting more "poor" people based on the poverty line. The rich are getting richer, and the poor are getting poorer.