Can women get a better deal on cars?
In a follow up email discussion with Tony, on his post 10 tips on getting a good deal when buying a car, an interesting point came up as to whether gender makes a difference in getting a good/better deal. Tony, argued that his wife actually went for the final negotiations at the car dealership and that helped them secure the best deal possible and real savings that he would not have been able to realize.
His logic was this: His wife (and women general?) is much more patient when it comes to negotiating so she was able to stay at the dealership for over 4 hours, talking to and pushing the salesman and his manager to provide the best deal possible. What's more is that she was able to feign ignorance (she knew it all) and stick to a price, by using lines like "Oh I don't know, my husband said that I can only pay $30,000 for this car.....but I really want this car; can't you do something to get this deal done". By having this stereotyped approach with the sales staff, where she was able to deflect any hard questions and play innocent to any probing ones, she basically wore down the salesman to get the best deal possible. Tony was on the phone at home in the event of any really tough questions or joint decisions that need to be made (and to watch their kids).
I asked Tony why he didn't just go himself and use the same act. His reply was that firstly, he doesn't have the patience and secondly he would not have been as effective (to the salesman) as his wife at pretending to be ignorant and unflinching on the sales price (i.e. playing to the gender stereotype of women and their lack of interest/knowledge around cars). This was one instance in which gender perceptions worked in their benefit. I probably wouldn't have thought about this tactic, but I can see how it would work. From the deal Tony got, it sounds like it definitely saved him a few hundred dollars.
Do you think gender differences and perceptions still play a big factor when buying a car? Would you use it to save money?
Picture courtesy: gbaku
Liked what you read? Then consider subscribing (free) to get the latest articles delivered directly via RSS or Email

September 18, 2008 3:22 PM
I actually find it to work the other way. Salesmen tend to look down on us and getting them to take us seriously is sometimes a challenge. I prefer to look and even buy online.
September 18, 2008 4:29 PM
(From PF Buzz) I'm counting on it. I've already told my husband that when we buy our first car, he can go ahead and be the impulsive guy (he has ADD so he's perfect for the role) and I'll be the mean wife who's too tight on the purse strings.
But I think you have to be prepared for every scenario. We'd also do our research, on the off-chance a salesman would actually treat us both as intelligent humans.
September 19, 2008 3:48 AM
I would think that dealers would actually view the genders differently. It's only human nature to do so.
But I think with Tony's situation, it's all about personality. I can stall, analyze, negotiate till their eyes fall out. My wife just wants it, and wants it yesterday.
It's more about personality than gender.
September 19, 2008 11:30 AM
@ Lynn - Not a bad way to do. I also just read somewhere that women are the main deciders of cars in their household, so perhaps the paridgm is shifting.
@ SG - Tag team tactics to save money - I like it. Reasearch and being prepared ar what make this tactic work.
@ PT - I agree, personality is very important and patience is the key trait. Still there is definetly some gender bias. I even noticed it a the mechanics the other day....
September 20, 2008 3:21 AM
I don't agree with this. Its because of her patience and her stereotype of ignorance. The her part doesn't matter.
Walk-in acting as though your the buyer but not the one with the money.
Be a stickler when it comes to the price.
Claim to only want to drive the car and not know about how the car works.
Make sure the salesmen knows that your doing them a service not the other way around. many customers forget this. The buyer is always in control, but the seller needs to make a positive amount to grow his business to keep up with demand.
September 20, 2008 3:22 AM
This post has been removed by the author.
September 23, 2008 7:32 PM
With my fiance it's the other way round. :)
I'll haggle the guy and get the best possible deal out of him.
If my fiance is with me she'll probably start feeling sorry for the poor dude and take his side! Hehe...
March 25, 2009 1:03 PM
I agree with the article. My wife and I wanted to buy a car... we found out the best price possible, and I called the dealership and said this is what I am willing to pay. The woman on the phone told me to come in and "we will talk". I gave phone to my wife and she told the woman that we have two month old infants and we are not driving 40 miles to just "talk". We want to make a deal on the phone. She was able to convience the woman over the phone in less than 5 minutes. We got the deal and car was ready when we got to the dealership. We got the car for much lower than the wholesale value... only because of my wife doing the dealing!
May 13, 2009 11:33 PM
Sweet talks always gets better deal. Women tends to keep their cool down until they get what they want.