Saving to Inve$t

Smart Personal Finance and Effective Money Management in Today's Economy

What would happen to My Money if Citigroup or Bank of America were Nationalized  

In an ominous sign that the financial and economic crisis has spread far and wide, a once laughable and highly unlikely event has come to pass. Our biggest banks are on the verge of being nationalized. That’s right – the government may soon step in and take over America’s biggest banks to save them from collapsing under all their expected debt obligations. But what would happen to your savings, shares and funds that are in these banks? Read on to find out.

Shares of banking giants Citigroup (C) and Bank of America (BAC) hit record lows today on real fears of them being nationalized (put under government control), following comments from influential Senate Banking Committee Chairman Christopher Dodd. White House press secretary Robert Gibbs tried to allay such concerns, saying President Barack Obama's administration thinks a "privately held" banking system is the correct way to go. However he refused to categorically rule out that nationalization may be required in the future.

The persistent weakness of financial stocks underscored deepening worries that months of unprecedented efforts by the Bush and Obama administrations to backstop nearly every corner of the U.S. banking system may not be enough to prevent the nationalization of some of the most wounded institutions. Both banks currently in question came out with statements today saying that they were financially sound and still lending. However a delayed and mixed response from government officials led to the sharp falls in stock prices over the day, despite a modest recovery following White house comments.

Still, the specter of nationalization is now much more real than it once was and you need to know how you will be affected if your bank is nationalized. Here is a breakdown:

Cash, CD and Other Savings held in the bank or its subsidiaries: Your savings are FDIC protected up to the authorized limits ($250,000), just as they are today. So you have little to worry about here since the FDIC is backed by the US government. Still it is always good to have at least a couple of bank accounts (a credit union is even better) to ensure that you have immediate access to cash while a nationalized bank is being taken over. Even if a bank is nationalized it does not mean it will close down. In fact like some recent FDIC takeovers, the process will be quite smooth with staff changes only at the C-level initially. Over time though there be more branch closings, more standardization across bank products and deterioration in customer service as the competitive drive disappears.

Shares invested in the Bank Stock (i.e. Shareholders): Similar to the take-over of GSE’s Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae, common and preferred shareholders will be wiped out. The fact that shareholders are the biggest losers in any nationalization, is the main reason that the stocks of Citigroup and Bank or America fell so sharply today.

Mutual or Exchange Traded Funds that have some investment in the bank’s stock: Most likely they will take a big hit, especially if they are financially focused funds. If it is a cross sector diversified fund the impact will be less because of the smaller financial sector exposure. So review your fund holdings to make sure that they are not too financially centric.

401K or IRA Plans that have invested in the Bank : If you work for one of these banks and have some of or all of your stocks in the bank, then you will be wiped out along with all the other common share holders. If your 401K plan has money invested in a fund then you will be affected like all other fund holders (see above point) and take a hit to your 401K or retirement account.

Other investors in the bank: Bondholders (corporate bonds are sold by the company to bondholders to raise money) MAY be protected if the government honors debt obligations. This will vary on bank-by-bank basis.

Brokerage and Wealth management customers: Banks like Citigroup and Bank or America have large brokerage and wealth management operations as well, which are not part of the core banking functions (saving and lending). If the government takes over, then it will most likely sell these off to private operators. Given brokerage and wealth management functions are quite profitable with low risk they will be easy to sell.

International Investors and Customers: In the case of Citigroup, its vast international scope would further complicate any U.S. government nationalization scheme, because that would run afoul of laws in other countries that restrict foreign governments from controlling domestic banks. In Mexico, for example, where Citigroup controls the nation's No. 2 bank by assets, a law restricts outside governments from owning more than 10% of a domestic bank. Most likely the company would be nationalized in America and operate as a separate entity for international purposes and eventually sold off to companies in the host country.

Despite the word “Nationalization” having a dreadful connotation, it has actually been done quite effectively in the past. Sweden took over its banks during their financial crisis and restored them to health and then privatized them again. France nationalized its banking sector, privatized it again by selling it into private hands and now may be in the process of another wave of nationalization. In the U.S., the government took over hundreds of institutions during the savings-and-loan crisis a couple of decades ago. It aggressively sold off bad assets, and the experiment is now regarded as a success.

We may just be entering another cycle of nationalization though, and the best thing you can do is get informed about its impacts on you and take the relevant actions. Hopefully this post will provide you with some of that information.

Related:

~ Is Citibank Going Bust by Offering a 3.5% APY!
~ Obama's $500,000 Pay Cap for Overpaid Financial Executives
~ Final Economic Stimulus and Recovery
~ Funding the Bailouts by Printing Money and Issuing Debt

Liked what you read? Then consider subscribing (free) to get the latest articles delivered directly via RSS or Email

Post a Comment

14 comments

  • MoneyEnergy  
    February 22, 2009 7:29 PM

    For all the comments/fears about Canada being a "socialist" country, it's interesting that it is the only country in the industrialized world to not have any bank failures, bailouts or mortgage bailouts during this whole mess... now the other G20 nations are taking Canada as an example especially following Obama's big endorsement.

  • Loans Modification  
    February 23, 2009 12:32 AM

    I think that there will be no big changes when it become nationalized..I don't expect much!!

  • American in Exile  
    February 23, 2009 9:26 AM

    I'm an expat with accounts at both BoA and Citi. My deposits are FDIC insured, but can anyone tell me whether nationalization would impair my ability to use internet banking?

  • Andy  
    February 23, 2009 9:35 AM

    Looks like the US government is stepping in yet again to save citibank! More taxpayer funds spent and national debt accumulated. Feel sorry for our future generations who have to pay off the debt.

    ME - Yep, the US got too smart for itself and the house of cards looks to have fallen. Canada and Australia probably have the soundest financial systems, yet stockmarkets in both countries have dropped more than the US...

    LM - I agree, infact I think the rest of the market will benefit from stabibiliy in the financial system. I think nationalization of BAC and C is only matter of time. With the government stakes increasing in both companies, they are already partially nationalized.

    American in Exile - Internet banking should not change. Nationalization means a change in ownership structure and unlikely the day to day operations will change much.

  • Anonymous  
    February 23, 2009 7:38 PM

    why do you say a credit union is better than a bank for access to cash in your post

  • Dollars blog  
    April 2, 2009 3:10 PM

    Great post. I was wondering about this whole situation because I'm concerned about all the money i have saved in my bank account.

  • Mortgage Loan Modifications  
    June 6, 2009 1:29 PM

    By nationalizing banks we are at the front door of becoming a post-communist state. I disagree with these measures.

  • Loan Modification  
    June 7, 2009 2:11 AM

    I wonder whether my money at a bank is increasingly at risk to be lost. If all banks go bankrupt what will come then?

  • Inmobiliaria.hu  
    June 11, 2009 3:03 AM

    Unfortunately banks will never go bankrupt. The government will alwys keep saving them. I hope some day the people will realise that it does not work forever. Then, we will have to start building a new system.

  • Shelly  
    July 2, 2009 1:56 AM

    Hi this is Shell..

    I am looking for some finance sites to make a relation between the sites by doing link swapping and article exchange.

    I have some good sites on finance and interested to do 3 way link exchange, so please let me know if you are interested to optimize site in SE, I will wait for ur reply at shellybrown1984(at)gmail.com

  • Inversion inmobiliaria  
    July 29, 2009 12:31 AM

    I think it is a natural process that we go through. Nationalization has taken place in communism, and it looks like the world has changed a lot and became clear that capitalism is not the most effective way to allocate resources. Communism did not work either so we have to find something inbetween.

  • Loan Modifications  
    July 31, 2009 3:36 AM

    Unfortunately I don't think it will impact anything.

  • mortgage loan modification  
    August 18, 2009 2:20 PM

    Lets hope that lenders aren't nationalized; while the burst of the housing bubble showed that we definitely need more regulation, our entire capitalist system is based upon a free market economy, in which we have to regulate ourselves through competition. Too much regulation is like forcing everyone to drive a Prius! Ick!

  • Bank account  
    August 25, 2009 8:46 AM

    Nationalization is inevitable. There is no other option to save C and BAC.
    Thank for this wonderful post. You have just provided me with valuable insights and ideas on what actions should be taken to protect my money in Citigroup. Good luck to us all.

Post a Comment

Recent Posts