Dave Ramsey, Suze Orman, and Other Financial Gurus – Is Their Advice Really Worth It?

4 comments

In today’s flip-flop economy, just about everyone has an opinion about what you should do with your money. From the din of these many opinions a few financial “gurus” seemed to have emerged. Some have become bona-fide celebrities by advising people on how to escape financial ruin, while making millions for themselves along the way by writing, preaching and berating those who are less financially enlightened.  And, although millions of people listen to these so called money-experts regularly, the question we should be asking ourselves is whether or not their advice is really worth it. Let’s look at two of the most well known money makeover experts for example.

Dave RamseyThe Total Money Makeover & The Seven Baby Steps to Financial peace

Dave Ramsey is a big-time financial guru who has a loyal and enthusiastic following. Ramsey teaches consumers how to get out of debt in addition to offering investment advice and has much more of a “tough love” style when he does so (based on his own experiences a long time ago). For some, this approach is exactly what is needed, while it can rub others the wrong way.

Overall, Ramsey offers some good pointers, like his 7 baby steps to reach financial peace. However, when it comes to some of the sub-areas of personal finance, some believe that he does not have any business offering advice. For example, some of Ramsey’s strategies on IRAs leave a lot to be desired – like downplaying the impact or consequences of taxes.

In addition, some of Ramsey’s information on mutual funds and hedge funds may not be 100 percent accurate either. For instance, his discussion of mutual fund expense ratios is off a bit as is his definition of a hedge fund – leading some readers of his website to question his knowledge in this area.

In spite of this, for those truly wishing to get out of debt by following some basic steps, Dave Ramsey does have some helpful tips. In particular he offers folks a decent way to get started with a financial plan by ridding themselves of debts and other obligations that could be holding them back from financial freedom.

Suze Orman The Money Class Book and The Suze Orman Show

Suze Orman has been touted by some as “America’s best known financial advisor.” She has supposedly helped millions of people, but it is questionable as to whether Orman has actually benefitted them financially in the long term.

On the positive side, Suze Orman’s outgoing personality style has helped many when it comes to actually facing up to the personal issues that surround money. For example, after listening to Orman, many people feel much more comfortable about investing and in facing their fears about making various financial moves.

However, when it comes to actual financial advice, Suze Orman has been considered a bit controversial in some areas. For example, she has been known to push for paying off your mortgage – even if it means excluding making investments in other areas. The result of this could leave investors with a huge chunk of their net worth in real estate and very little everywhere else – including an emergency fund.

In addition, she also errs on the conservative side. In fact, in her own personal portfolio, Orman admits to only having about 4 percent of her assets in the stock market with a large percentage of the rest in municipal bonds. And, while this strategy may be thought of as safe, it is not practical for the average investor who is hoping at the very least to beat inflation and grow their assets to keep their purchasing power in line with rising prices.

Conclusion

So, while financial gurus may provide advice that makes people feel good, the truth is that feeling good is not what makes your money grow. People need to receive their financial advice from those who have a good understanding and knowledge about their individual situation, financial habits and actual aspirations.

I would definitely recommend you consider what these gurus have to say, because you will soon realize that getting out of debt is not impossible and just requires some discipline and common sense. But don’t rush in and pay for all the extra services these gurus (and their companies/affiliates) try and up-sell to you, without assessing them thoroughly. After all in many cases, free advice is free for a reason.

Leave a Reply

4 Comments on "Dave Ramsey, Suze Orman, and Other Financial Gurus – Is Their Advice Really Worth It?"


Devin
Saturday 9:08 am

Dave Ramsey rubs me the wrong way. He may be a good kick start for deadbeats but I can’t stand his endless self promotion and his blowhard comments.

febsky
Tuesday 3:23 pm

I am currently attending a video seminar of Dave Ramsey and it’s amazing how we just need a butt kick to make us realize that we need a budget as a family. The 13 week seminar has TONS of very practical application and he really nailed down the issues that an average family face: undisciplined life, lack of financial understanding, lack of financial skills. All these things are addressed in the Financial Peace University. I’ve seen our attitude (me and hubby) changed a lot and have a financial goal in mind. Although some of his pointers are still hard to reach (to be able to not worry about credit scores since you don’t need it), he really gives a lot of good sense.

Ravi Gupta
Sunday 5:20 pm

I think everyone has to do their own due diligence. Having read up on them both and having done my own research you can see where they both fall short. Every investment portfolio will be different depending on a persons risk preference. These articles by both authors are meant for broad general advice.

-Ravi Gupta

Frank
Tuesday 8:44 am

How many people have you helped Ravi? Who are you?

wpDiscuz

Previous post:

Next post:

Disclaimer: The information contained on Saving to Invest (this site) is for general information purposes only and does not constitute factual or professional financial advice. In accordance with FTC guidelines, we disclose that we may have a financial relationship with some of the merchants/companies mentioned on this website. We do our best to maintain current information, but due to the rapidly changing environment, some information may have changed since it was published. Please do the appropriate research before participating in any third party offers. Refer to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use for more information