Traditional IRA versus Roth IRA – Contribution and Phase-out Income Limits


I regularly receive reader questions asking me to clarify the difference between a Roth IRA and Traditional IRA plan. Both are excellent retirement investment vehicles, but based on your income and tax situation one may be a better first choice than the other. Here are some key differences and a summary table of the two retirement investment options for easy reference. At the end of the article are the article are links to more resources and annual updates. You can see this article for a step-by-step walk through of choosing the best retirement plan for you.

[Click here for a list of the best, low cost IRA brokers]

Traditional IRA

A Traditional IRA offers a tax-deferred retirement investment option, with investors being able to deduct all or part of their contributions from pretax income if certain conditions are met. This also makes it an effective way to reduce current tax obligations – particularly for those in  higher income tax brackets.

There are no income limitations on being able to contribute to a Traditional IRA, but you must be under age 70½ and have earned income. You must also have earned income equal to or greater than your contributions.

You generally pay taxes when you make withdrawals, at which time you may be in a lower tax bracket. If you withdraw before the official retirement age (59 ½), you will also have to pay additional penalties unless you can prove extenuating circumstances (like spouse death, hardship, disability and qualified medical expenses).

All withdrawals from a Traditional IRA (except for amounts attributable to nondeductible contributions) are generally taxed as ordinary income – a key difference to Roth IRA’s. You must begin taking required minimum distributions by April 1 of the year following the year in which you reach age 70½.

You’re eligible for a fully deductible IRA contribution if neither you nor your spouse participates in an employer-sponsored (401K) retirement plan. If either of you do participate in such a plan, your ability to deduct your full IRA contribution may be limited by your income.

Roth IRA

A Roth IRA, like a traditional IRA, is a tax effective/differed retirement savings plan. Unlike the traditional IRA though, once you reach age 59½, you may qualify for tax-free withdrawals of both contributions and any accumulated earnings. In addition, you’re never required to take distributions, making a Roth IRA an effective option for both retirement and estate planning purposes.

Further, you may realize tax savings if you think your tax bracket in retirement will be higher than your current rate. A five-year holding period required for tax-free withdrawals regardless of investor’s age.The Roth IRA is subject to penalties if withdrawn early, but up to $10,000 in earnings may be withdrawn tax-free if used for a qualified first-time home purchase.

The Roth IRA is also an effective inheritance vehicle because you may potentially reduce or eliminate the taxes your beneficiaries will have to pay after inheriting. You may be able to contribute to a Roth IRA for yourself or your spouse if you have earned income.

The IRS releases 401K and IRA Limits on an annual basis that are updated based on cost of living adjustments (COLA). The main impact to IRA and Roth IRA plans are the income eligibility/phase-out limits. You can click the links below to see the latest annual limits or go to the 401k/IRA resource page.

Leave a Reply

20 Comments on "Traditional IRA versus Roth IRA – Contribution and Phase-out Income Limits"

Notify of

[…] amount must be made after taxes and do not reduce your salary for tax purposes. (see the latest Traditional and Roth IRA Limits […]

[…] options. For most people two types of IRA options are best – a Traditional IRA or a Roth IRA (see a comparison). But choosing the right option depends on a variety of factors that include, how much you and/or […]

[…] You can make contributions to your Roth IRA after you reach age 70 ½, unlike traditional IRA plans […]

[…] that the above are the maximum contributions you can deduct for all of your traditional AND Roth IRAs in the 2012 tax year. The IRA contribution limits does not apply to rollover […]

[…] See this article for more IRA plan rules and contribution limits […]

[…] of the contribution and deduction rules for 401K and IRA type plans will stay the same. IRA to Roth IRA conversions, irrespective of income, will still be […]

[…] plan at your job and your MAGI is more than $110,000, you are not entitled to deduct any of your traditional IRA contributions in the applicable tax year.  You are eligible to make non-deductible contributions, […]

[…] providing financial security in retirement. You can make a deductible IRA contribution (subject to income limits) as late as April 15 of the subsequent tax year, but the earlier you start the more likely you […]

[…] IRA are self-run tax-deferred retirement plans with investors being able to deduct all or part of their contributions from pretax income if certain conditions are met. Like a 401K, the official retirement age at which you can make penalty free withdrawals is 59½. You also may owe an excise tax if you do not begin to withdraw minimum distributions by April 1st of the year after you reach age 70½. […]

[…] is an account that you can start on your own that has certain rules attached to it that make it specific for retirement. This gives you complete control of how your […]

[…] What is the biggest difference between a 401K Plan and an Individual Retirement Account (IRA) […]

[…] You can make a deductible 2010 IRA contribution as late as April 15, 2011, provided you meet the income requirements. Alternatively, if you can’t make a deductible IRA contribution, you may still be able to […]

[…] those making more than $100,000 a year in adjusted income – will be allowed to convert to Roth IRA accounts from Traditional IRAs. That means that more than 15 million Americans, can consider whether they want to make […]

[…] the average IRA contribution is $3,798, many Americans are still contributing too much to their traditional IRA or Roth IRA account without realizing it. The combined limit for a traditional and/or Roth IRA accounts is […]

[…] the path that leads to financial safety in retirement is lined with lots of superb tax advantaged options (like IRA’s, 401K’s and Roth IRAs) since the government wants to encourage self funded […]

[…] in an employer plan.  The chart here summarizes the options and key differences. Basically the key differences are the tax treatment of contributions you make and tighter income restrictions for Roth IRAs. The […]

[…] If you are thinking of investing in the rising stock market or just looking to start an IRA then you need an online broker. In today’s online world there are lots of good choices, but the […]

Penny Stock Trading Strategies
Sunday 6:04 pm

>The tax rates will fluctuate each year based on various variables. I have a Roth IRA and I make sure to put more into it each year. Thanks for the great article.

Daddy Paul
Saturday 2:51 am

>Your 2010 tax rate may be lower than your 2011 and 2012 tax rate. I for one have more interest in converting this year and taking the income this year as opposed to delaying paying taxes until 2011 and 2012.

Shaun McGowan
Friday 11:37 pm

>I recommend investigating your personal situation and investing in whichever plan you decide is best for you. If you are eligible for both, you also have the option of splitting your investment to take advantage of tax benefits now, and in retirement.


Previous post:

Next post:

Disclaimer: The information contained on Saving to Invest (this site) is for general information purposes only and does not constitute factual or professional financial advice. In accordance with FTC guidelines, we disclose that we may have a financial relationship with some of the merchants/companies mentioned on this website. We do our best to maintain current information, but due to the rapidly changing environment, some information may have changed since it was published. Please do the appropriate research before participating in any third party offers. Refer to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use for more information