Why Vanguard and Fidelity Money Market Funds Are a Money Losing Proposition. Go For A High Yield Savings Account Instead

4 comments

I recently got an email saying that my Vanguard prime money market fund’s expense ratio had increased from 0.16% to 0.17%. Not such a big deal because even with the higher expense ratio, Vanguard’s prime money market fund fees are still amongst the lowest in the industry. But what caught my attention when I went to review the account was that the SEC yield on the money market account has dropped to 0.01%, so technically I am losing or paying Vanguard 0.16% to park my money there. I also saw this discrepancy with Fidelity and T.Rowe Price, the other big provider of ultra-safe money market funds, which had similar fees and returns. Clearly I need to rectify this situation and find a better place to park my emergency/liquid savings.

Vanguard Money Market Fund

Go for the High Yield Savings Account Instead

I know money market accounts are primarily used to safely park money because they never “break-the-buck,” but the fact that the expense ratio is greater than the yield (return) distorts this hypothesis. It would actually be much more cost effective to park my money in a higher yield savings account that have no expense or account fees. For example, the best high yield savings account currently has a 0.75% APY (annual percentage yield) that is essentially 75 times what you can get with a money market fund. And thanks to the FDIC insurance on these accounts the money is as safe or even more so than it is with a money market account.

I already have the above high yield savings account and have completed the transaction to move the funds out of my money market account prior to writing this article. It only took a couple of days since I have to go through my Wells Fargo checking account which links to both accounts. But opening a new high yield account (see this list for a few good options) doesn’t take long and within a few days you can actually start making, rather than losing, money on the most liquid of your cash savings.

Leave a Reply

4 Comments on "Why Vanguard and Fidelity Money Market Funds Are a Money Losing Proposition. Go For A High Yield Savings Account Instead"

Yvette

Thanks for this post. I was thinking about moving money from the Capitol One 360 Savings to the Vanguard Prime Market Fund and noticed the issue. Then called Vanguard to double check the APY. Was very surprised. I’ll keep my money where it currently is. I’ve been using Capitol One since 2011. While it’s not always the high rate savings account, it’s always near the top. Prefer to park my money in one place and save the effort of transferring accounts from one place to another. Time costs money!

James2

I second what James above stated, but I must respectfully correct him on the American Express Savings account current interest rate that is now paying .90%. This was raised after the Fed Increased the Interest rate earlier this month by .5%. So yes, I too would not want Capital One in my wallet, but rather American Express!

Adam

The yield calculated AFTER the expense ratio is taken into account. So, you are not losing money.

James

Try a savings account from American Express @ .85% that beats your rate from Capital One who I personally would NOT have in my wallet. However I would use American Express as my card of choice. JMHO!

wpDiscuz

Previous post:

Next post: