Paying Too Much For Your Auto Insurance? Get a Better Rate For Free and Save on Your Renewal


The AARP recently released it’s auto insurance premium review which provides a good benchmark for checking whether the auto insurance you are paying is consistent with national and state averages. If it is not, then you should be looking to for a better rate with your current provider or find a new one elsewhere (or move to a state with cheaper insurance!)

With the hundred’s of insurers out there,  you can spend hours searching for the most cost effective auto insurance. So to make things faster and more efficient I recommend you start searching  for the best premiums through insurance search portals and with some of the bigger/well-known providers. Insurance portals allow you to search across multiple providers in one place while economies of scale allow the bigger auto insurance companies to provide lower premiums/more options and they generally have much better customer service (especially following an accident).


This insurance company, owned by Warren Buffet’s Berkshire Hathaway, is well know thanks to it’s incessant advertising and actually does have one of the easiest to use websites, with clear guidance on key terms and coverage options.  I really liked their online feature that automatically obtained my vehicle and driver information from motor vehicle departments and other groups (once I entered some personal information). This allowed me to get a faster and more accurate quote, without having to type in all my car information.

It took me around 5 minutes to get a premium estimate (broken down by each insurance item) that I could easily customize to see what impacts changing one or more factors would have on the premium. I tried about four variations  (like a low deductible and rental car insurance), which really allowed me to really understand what factors were driving my insurance premium rate.

Esurance (Insurance Portal)

This insurance portal is now pretty well known thanks to it’s extensive advertising campaign on providing discounted car insurance quote. They act like a broker between you and the other insurance companies and given their discount guarantee they are definitely worth visiting in this ultra competitive autp insurance market. Their insurance premium quote was comparable with GEICO, and if their premium was a bit lower I would have gone with them.

The AARP Auto Insurance Program (for drivers over 50) –  Another program I came across while researching this article was insurance programs for those over 50. Provided by AARP, the rates are up to 15% lower than average for eligbile drivers with good driving records. If you (or your spouse) are over 50, I would definitely get a quote from AARP to see if you can benefit from a Seniors discount

Normally I get a 3-4 online auto insurance quotes when my policy is due for renewal and then call the representative of my current insurance provider to see if they can match the lowest priced policy (with comparable options to my current coverage). Most of them have a +/- 10% discretion, so you can normally get a decent deal this way (and stay with your current provider), particularly if you have a good driving record. If they cannot match it and the savings are substantial enough, I go with another reputable auto insurance provider.

Leave a Reply

4 Comments on "Paying Too Much For Your Auto Insurance? Get a Better Rate For Free and Save on Your Renewal"

Notify of

[…] using companies suggested to them by the professionals surround them, and then they never end up following up on quotes with the companies they’re already insured with. However, taking that extra amount of time to […]

[…] the story goes on say, the average auto insurance premium — for liability, comprehensive and collision coverage — was about $901 (or $450 semi-annually). […]

[…] despite significant savings to be had by shopping around. Based on anecdotal evidence and a recent AARP survey, which looked at the average insurance costs by state, it is likely that folks could easily save up […]

[…] companies offer. But there are some discounts that almost every driver can get. Here are six car insurance discounts you should already have or be trying to […]


Previous post:

Next post:

Disclaimer: The information contained on Saving to Invest (this site) is for general information purposes only and does not constitute factual or professional financial advice. In accordance with FTC guidelines, we disclose that we may have a financial relationship with some of the merchants/companies mentioned on this website. We do our best to maintain current information, but due to the rapidly changing environment, some information may have changed since it was published. Please do the appropriate research before participating in any third party offers. Refer to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use for more information